i30 Owners Club

Road Test & Economy Test tricks

AlanHo · 12 · 3446

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline AlanHo

  • Global Moderator
  • *
  • Geriatric Teenager
    • Posts: 21,468

    • england England
      Solihull, UK

  • 2021 KIA Niro 3 1.6 Petrol Hybrid
I had a pint or three with a neighbour last evening who recently retired from his job as a development engineer for a UK motor manufacturer.

I was asking him why so many bugs find their way into the new cars after the extensive testing programme they carry out to engineer and develop a new model. He explained that very early in the development cycle the company will set a final launch date for a new model - possibly 12 to 18 months ahead. During the ongoing test programme various bugs will be found, a solution proposed and the required amendment channeled through the design, development, production engineering and tooling departments.  More often than not this cycle will be repeated several times before an optimum solution is agreed. This process can take many months - even for a simple change.

Postponing a set launch date is a frightfully expensive business and for financial and marketing reasons cars are often launched onto the market with known problems - for which a solution is in the pipe-line - that will have to be resolved by the dealers when the fix becomes available.

He also chatted at length about how cars are prepared for motoring press road tests and for the government economy tests. I can't remember all that he said but a few points stick in my mind like :-

Fitting an "optimised" water pump, oil pump and alternator that use less power but are man enough for the planned tests.

A total engine, fuel system and power train re-build using finely tolerance matched components.  This includes the optimal tensioning/setting of belts, chains and valve gear.

A very carefully mapped ECU - it is nothing for them to spend a couple of months on this aspect alone

Minimising oil levels to avoid churning power loss.

Careful choice of wheel bearings and drive shafts to minimise NHV (noise harshness and vibration)

Having the tyres ground on the wheel to achieve a perfectly circular tread - this reduces rolling resistance and NHV

Ensuring that all the components underneath the car are fitted such that the best aerodynamic condition is achieved - they are not modified - but he said that the exhaust system, aero panels and pipe runs under the car are "optimised".

I suppose that we should not be surprised by all this - after all - it's a competitive business.


  • 2021 KIA Niro3 1.6 petrol Hybrid


Offline Doggie 1

  • V.I.P
  • *
  • Doggie Connoisseur
    • Posts: 31,103

    • au Australia
      Perth

  • 2019 PD2 Go Petrol, Manual. 30,000 kms.
Very interesting.
It's a pity they can't do some of these things for all of us.
  • Tertius the i30


Offline asathorny

  • V.I.P
  • *
  • Wonky Donkey
    • Posts: 6,635

    • england England
      Manchester City centre

  • Curmudgeon

Offline Dazzler

  • Admin
  • *
  • Laughter is the best medicine...
    • Posts: 67,423

    • au Australia
      Devonport Tasmania

  • Best Car Forum on the Net
That is very interesting Alan... :goodjob: 

I have read a few reviews over the years where one of these "mules" as they call them have done the rounds and my the time it gets to ABC Magazine it is decidedly 2nd hand in several areas  :whistler:
  • 2021 MG PHEV ( had 4 x i30 plus a Getz an Elantra and a Tucson)


Offline eye30

  • Global Moderator
  • *
  • HOS BOSS
    • Posts: 27,366

    • england England
      Wirral

  • Wirral, UK. - 1.4 Petrol Active - Aqua Blue
I wonder whether that explains why test reports seem to praise certain marques and not others.

Is it down to the how a particular car is "dressed up" for the big day.
  • 1.4 Petrol Active I'm no expert, so please correct me if


Offline Asterix

  • V.I.P
  • *
  • i40 CRDi 100kW 2013
    • Posts: 4,434

    • dk Denmark
      Sdr. Omme - DK
Another reason why we cant obtain the promised fuel consumption.  :disapp:
  • i40 CRDi 100 kW 2013


Offline AlanHo

  • Global Moderator
  • *
  • Geriatric Teenager
    • Posts: 21,468

    • england England
      Solihull, UK

  • 2021 KIA Niro 3 1.6 Petrol Hybrid
Another reason why we cant obtain the promised fuel consumption.  :disapp:

I did say in my post
Quote
I suppose that we should not be surprised by all this - after all - it's a competitive business.
  • 2021 KIA Niro3 1.6 petrol Hybrid


Offline Asterix

  • V.I.P
  • *
  • i40 CRDi 100kW 2013
    • Posts: 4,434

    • dk Denmark
      Sdr. Omme - DK
Another reason why we cant obtain the promised fuel consumption.  :disapp:

I did say in my post
Quote
I suppose that we should not be surprised by all this - after all - it's a competitive business.

I did see that, but in my opinion it's still cheating  :exclaim:  :fum:

Only positive thing about this is that the roadtax gets lower.
  • i40 CRDi 100 kW 2013


Offline rustynutz

  • Top Gear
  • *
    • Posts: 17,513

    • au Australia
      South Gippsland
I know that sort of thing went on in the motorcycle industry many years ago....  :fum:

But I'd be very surprised if it happens in either industry to a huge degree these days... :undecided:


Offline constipated

  • 4th Gear
  • *
    • Posts: 464

    • au Australia
      Sydney
Why don't they do like crash testing whereby they purchase a car anonymously, or turn up unannounced when requesting a car to get an unmodified version.
  • MY11 - SLX CRDi 6 speed manual


Offline Hati

  • V.I.P
  • *
    • Posts: 561

    • au Australia
      Perth WA
Why don't they do like crash testing whereby they purchase a car anonymously, or turn up unannounced when requesting a car to get an unmodified version.


Because the media loves to feel important and be invited to all expenses paid car launches. Also many upmarket cars (Lambo, Ferrari etc) would not be available to the number of media reps a launch event can cater for.


For us mare mortals the only thing left is to take all the hype and "first look/drive" dribble with a large grain of salt, unless they test something "off the shelf".
  • 2017 i30 Elite PD


Offline Dazzler

  • Admin
  • *
  • Laughter is the best medicine...
    • Posts: 67,423

    • au Australia
      Devonport Tasmania

  • Best Car Forum on the Net
I don't doubt that Alan's Neighbour was telling the truth about what happens sometimes ...

I think the difference between a specially prepared car and one "off the shelF" may not be as big as it would have once been though...

Without the variables of carbies etc.. and most things now being computer controlled i'm sure that what you get in the show room is not that far removed  :cool:
  • 2021 MG PHEV ( had 4 x i30 plus a Getz an Elantra and a Tucson)


Unread Posts

 


SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal